PaulHumph
Joined
Sept. 30, 2024
About
After playing thief and Thief 2 when they were first released, I had a very long hiatus and then discovered the fan missions a year or so ago
As i appreciate the amount of hard work that goes into the creation of a mission, good or bad, I'm unlikely to leave a negative review. I do try to leave reviews and ratings for the missions that I enjoy. I will rate low if I think the mission deserves it.
I like: -
Good architecture, good gameplay, atmosphere, puzzles that aren't wildly difficult or obscure to solve, vertical missions
I dislike: -
zombies or any other undead (can't see the point in Thief), getting stuck in windows or other small places, jumps between ledges that require pinpoint accuracy and 100 attempts, readables that go on for several pages and add nothing to the story, doors/trunks that require several changes of lockpick & take half an hour to open, puzzles that are totally baffling to anyone but the author.
★ 8 / 10 The Sunken Library, Aug. 11, 2026
★ 8 / 10 Recipe for Turmoil, March 23, 2026
★ 9 / 10 My Favorite Year, March 21, 2026
★ 7 / 10 Off The Record, March 19, 2026
★ 8 / 10 Burrick's Head Inn, March 18, 2026
★ 7 / 10 Eastwater Bank, March 17, 2026
★ 7 / 10 Gerrard's Temple, March 15, 2026
★ 8 / 10 Precarious Business, March 10, 2026
★ 9 / 10 The Drymian Codex, March 2, 2026
★ 7 / 10 The Fever, Feb. 24, 2026
★ 8 / 10 Ashes and Dust, Feb. 24, 2026
★ 8 / 10 Wicked Relics, Feb. 24, 2026
★ 7 / 10 Nostalgia, Feb. 21, 2026
★ 6 / 10 A Mother's Love, Feb. 20, 2026
★ 9 / 10 Vagabond, Feb. 20, 2026
★ 7 / 10 The Affairs of Wizards, Feb. 16, 2026
★ 8 / 10 Feast of Pilgrims, Feb. 15, 2026
★ 9 / 10 Behind Closed Doors, Feb. 7, 2026
I remember little about this mission but I gave it a good score as I must have enjoyed it at the time.
I read most of the reviews on here and I'm baffled by some of the missions that reviewers enjoy* (and sometimes wax lyrical over). I try them and give up after a few minutes . Some I've persevered with and still thought I'd wasted several hours of my life.
As most things in life, it's all subjective.
*That includes some reviewers whose recommendations are mostly to my liking.
Where can I download this? There are three links on Thief Guild: Taffers Paradise; The BoycoT & Dark Fate.
My browser won't open the first link, even though it's allowed. I can't see it on The BoycoT (I've searched by name & author - there is another mission by Qolelis). I can only see a link to the Russian version on Dark Fate.
Thanks.
I finished this one yesterday. Totally agree with the small switches - I did a room by room search after an initial sweep found nothing.
The key that I struggled to find was the early in the mission one that had been dropped in the sewers. Despite swimming in every available part several times, I had to watch Fen's video on YT. Apart from that, with a struggle, I found the rest.
A great mission. Some of the readables were a touch on the verbose side but of course well written.
I didn't see Fen's video on this one. I always enjoy his walkthroughs.