★ 7 / 10 The Hardest Way To Make An Easy Living, Sept. 19, 2025
★ 9 / 10 Venomous Ambition, Sept. 18, 2025
★ 6 / 10 Darkstone Gem chapter 1, parts 1-4: Unconventional Intermediator, Sept. 14, 2025
★ 5 / 10 Stealthy Business, Sept. 14, 2025
★ 6 / 10 A Heretic's Intervention, Sept. 13, 2025
★ 7 / 10 Broken Gears, Sept. 13, 2025
★ 7 / 10 Profitable Lockdown, Sept. 12, 2025
★ 6 / 10 A Visit for the Knights, Sept. 12, 2025
★ 8 / 10 Bones: Episode 1: the Old Quarter, Sept. 12, 2025
★ 6 / 10 Down With Mechanists, Sept. 10, 2025
★ 8 / 10 Geller's Pride, Sept. 7, 2025
★ 4 / 10 Having a Ball, Sept. 5, 2025
★ 6 / 10 The Unbidden Guest, Aug. 31, 2025
★ 7 / 10 Prowler of the Dark, Aug. 31, 2025
★ 3 / 10 Hunt for Montrose, Aug. 31, 2025
★ 4 / 10 Ramirez's Revenge Ver. 2, Aug. 31, 2025
★ 5 / 10 The Perdurance, Aug. 31, 2025
★ 7 / 10 Morning Light, Aug. 31, 2025
Whoa, if this is 4/10, then I really want to see you rate other big Newdark missions ^
Yeah, it’s challenging, but if anything, it’s one of the FAIREST of the challenging FMs I’ve ever played.
And while everyone’s entitled to their opinion on pacing or puzzles, rating this a 4 in terms of atmosphere is simply ridiculous from someone who’s played any Thief before. No way around it.
Well, I'd agree with almost all of your criticisms in essence (maybe except the design being unappealing and boring - I mean, it gets like that at times, but it's not universally bad), but I'd still say a 4 is a bit harsh, considering how much novelty this set would offer in its time. Let's remember it's 2006. Sure, looking at it through the lens of today's standards won't do it any good, but then, it's not like today's missions don't have their own gameplay issues and their averages still go...
We accepted the suggestion to change the categories of Ura, submitted by andyln, Jan. 17, 2025
We accepted the suggestion to change the categories of Coalport, submitted by andyln, Dec. 21, 2024
We accepted the suggestion to change the categories of A Love Story 4, submitted by andyln, March 9, 2024
We accepted the suggestion to change the categories of Bad Blood 2, submitted by andyln, Feb. 11, 2024
We accepted the suggestion to change the missions_in_campaign of Bad Blood 2, submitted by andyln, Feb. 11, 2024